2001: A Space Odyssey - S. Kubrick masterpiece - Page 3

W_z_rd · Aug 29, 2003, 09:37

Interesno, kto-nibud` videl etot fil`m, krome ForeverChild-a i Leshkina (a-uuu) ?
Eto bezuslovno luchshiy iz fil`mov, kotorie ya videl tut, v USA i luchshiy fantasticheskiy fil`m iz kogda-libo vidennix mnoy.
Fil`m vizyval i vyzivaet samie protivorechivie otkliki. Dlya odnix eto otkrovenie (kak dlya menya), dlya drugix - skuchnaya mura. Fil`m etot o cheloveke i chelovechestve: o ego proshlom, nastoyashem i budushem. O progresse (texnicheskom i ne tol`ko) chelovechestva i o smisle etogo progressa.
Interesno uslishat` mnenie tex, kto sumel dosmotret` etot til`m do konca.

Helen · Sep 3, 2003, 14:34

neMarina : kasatel`no tvoego voprosa - mne kazhesja, chto prisutsvie strasti v zhizni vsegda objazatel`no , ne tol`ko po otnosheniju k iskusstvu

.

Nu, chto kasaetsja Odissei - mozhet, i vprjam` prosto ne tvoe?
Menja vot zatjanulo s samyh pervyh kadrov

W_z_rd · Sep 3, 2003, 16:12

Quote:

Originally posted by neMarina
W_z_rd jan, spasibo za comments... nemnozhko proyasnilos'...
Xotya ne ubedilo
Vopros (pochti topic): Obyazatel'no li prisutstvie strasti v "piece of iskusstvo" ili dostatochno togo, chtob ono bylo professional'no otrabotannym i stil'nym?

NMV - obyazatel`no, xotya drugie s etim mogut ne soglasit`sya. No kak raz u Kubrika v fil`max moment strasti vsegda prisutsvuet, xotya i v otrabotannom i stil`nom variante. Vzyat`, xotya by, poslednie kadri "Odissei", ili scenu rasstrela snaypershi v "FMJ", o kotoroy govoril groul.
Bol`shinstvo xudozhnikov tvoryat serdcem: u nix sozrevaet chto-to na dushe i oni vylivayut eto na bumagu, plenku, kamen`, itd. Kak pravilo na etom tvorchestvo u nix zakanchivaetsya. Kubrik etim ne ogranichivaetsya, ona nachinaet ottachivat` poluchennoe, ottachivat`, snova i snova, poka ne poluchit` udovletvoryayushiy ego rezul`tat. Tut chto-to, vidimo, poxozhee na podxodi Mozarta i Salieri.

neMarina · Sep 4, 2003, 05:35

Ya kazhetsya propustila otmechennie epizody

Ladny, poka ne posmotryu, bol'she ni ni! Molchu!

R.P. McMurphy · Nov 6, 2003, 12:53

Великолепный фильм. Смотрел его раз 5. И не откажусь снова посмотреть.

View Poll Results: Videli li vi etot film ?
Ne videl, i ne zhelayu	0	0%
Ne videl, no xotel by posmotret`	6	35.29%
Menya xvatilo na pervie 20 min etoy muri	4	23.53%
Umudrilsya deosmotret` fil`m do konca	7	41.18%
Voters: 17. You may not vote on this poll

Sep 3, 2003, 14:34	#31
Helen Moderator Join Date: Sep 2002 Location: Armenia Posts: 1,142 Rep Power: 6 Reputation: 44	neMarina : kasatel`no tvoego voprosa - mne kazhesja, chto prisutsvie strasti v zhizni vsegda objazatel`no , ne tol`ko po otnosheniju k iskusstvu . Nu, chto kasaetsja Odissei - mozhet, i vprjam` prosto ne tvoe? Menja vot zatjanulo s samyh pervyh kadrov __________________ And everything under the Sun is in tune, But the Sun is eclipsed by the Moon.(Pink Floyd)

Sep 4, 2003, 05:35	#33
neMarina Cheloveka! Join Date: May 2003 Location: Burkina Faso Posts: 314 Rep Power: 6 Reputation: 10	Ya kazhetsya propustila otmechennie epizody Ladny, poka ne posmotryu, bol'she ni ni! Molchu! __________________ Душа за время жизни приобретает смертные черты...

Nov 6, 2003, 12:53	#34
R.P. McMurphy Душевноздоровый Join Date: Oct 2002 Location: Комбинат, Конд, Ереван Posts: 8,938 Rep Power: 7 Reputation: 26	Великолепный фильм. Смотрел его раз 5. И не откажусь снова посмотреть. __________________ Ты надул их, Вождь. Ты их всех надул! ---------------------------------------------- Oh, woman, you make me wanna ooooh! ---------------------------------------------- www.AlterEgo.am \| Armenian Rock Band

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Aug 29, 2003, 09:37
W_z_rd Академик Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: Yerevan, Armenia Posts: 4,443 Rep Power: 6 Reputation: 41	2001: A Space Odyssey - S. Kubrick masterpiece Interesno, kto-nibud` videl etot fil`m, krome ForeverChild-a i Leshkina (a-uuu) ? Eto bezuslovno luchshiy iz fil`mov, kotorie ya videl tut, v USA i luchshiy fantasticheskiy fil`m iz kogda-libo vidennix mnoy. Fil`m vizyval i vyzivaet samie protivorechivie otkliki. Dlya odnix eto otkrovenie (kak dlya menya), dlya drugix - skuchnaya mura. Fil`m etot o cheloveke i chelovechestve: o ego proshlom, nastoyashem i budushem. O progresse (texnicheskom i ne tol`ko) chelovechestva i o smisle etogo progressa. Interesno uslishat` mnenie tex, kto sumel dosmotret` etot til`m do konca. __________________ Stuck between heaven and hell; dunno where to go...